In the closest, most relevant comparison, the iconic image of

Legend or Myth

canada goose Inside Edo CTVEdo South BeninEGORIKPOBA OKHAOREDOORHIONMWONOVIA NORTHOVIA SOUTHUHUNMWUNODEEdo Central EsanEdo North Etsakko canada goose

Adam and Eve:?

canada goose black friday sale Most sophisticated theologians do not canada goose outlet toronto location consider the Garden of Eden story about Adam and Eve (and a talking snake) historical. Most people, including the Catholic Priest Dwight Longenecker, consider the Garden of Eden story a legend with heavy canada goose outlet woodbury saturation of mythical elements. Those who are even more skeptical, such as myself, claim it is outright fable coupled with Sumerian folklore and the transcribed into the Jewish faith and nothing more. I have written about why I do not believe Adam and Eve existed in what is my most frequented blog post on this site, “Adam and Eve Never Existed: It’s a Myth!” This is the long awaited follow up canada goose outlet to that canada goose outlet belgium essay. canada goose black friday sale

canada goose clearance sale On his blog Standing on My Head, Father Longenecker challenges us by asking: canada goose clearance sale

Canada Goose online Why does it matter if the first twelve chapters of Genesis are recounting historical events or not? Canada Goose online

Canada Goose Parka It matters because the whole canada goose outlet houston rest of the Old Testament record is clearly a presentation of God’s interaction in history God’s interaction in the history of the Hebrew people, and this historical canada goose outlet store uk interaction lays the foundation for the ultimate historical interaction by God with his people the incarnation of his Son. Canada Goose Parka

canada goose deals He goes on to clarify: canada goose deals

What do I mean when I say that these stories ‘act on us as myth does’?

Canada Goose Outlet Myth connects with the deeper parts of our shared consciousness within our humanity. Great stories of mythical heroes who go on a quest, interactions with gods and goddesses, all the great stories of the world canada goose outlet phone number engage us at a deep level and we connect with the events and drama in a ceremonial and symbolic way using a language that is deeper than words and explications. Canada Goose Outlet

cheap Canada Goose Although men of faith usually will have a certain level of confirmation bias, such as depicted in Father Longenecker’s comment that “Myth connects with the deeper parts of our shared consciousness within our humanity. Great stories of mythical heroes who go on a quest, interactions with gods and goddesses, all the great stories of the world engage us at a deep level and we connect with the events and drama in a ceremonial and symbolic way using a language that is deeper than canada goose outlet store quebec words and explications. The stories of the beginning of Genesis do as well, with the exception that these are not fanciful stories as the pagan myths are, but stories based in real events.” cheap Canada Goose

canada goose clearance Personally, I find Father Longenecker’s claim that the Adam and Eve story is a legend rooted canada goose outlet sale in historical truth a little far fetched. After all, the tale of King Arthur is a legend, Robin Hood is a legend, Jolly old St. Nicholas has been lengendized and mythologized, but Adam and Eve have never been proved to be anything other than mythical. canada goose clearance

Canada Goose Jackets Simple. We can ask the following: which part of the story is historically accurate exactly? Could it be the part about a man being made from clay? According to Genesis 2:7 “And the Lord god formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into canada goose outlet in new york his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.” Well, sorry to say, but we know this is false. Mankind did not evolve from a clump of clay, we evolved from a common ancestor (a scientifically validated fact). Canada Goose Jackets

Perhaps more importantly however, we know the claim that God forged first man from clay is not at all uncommon to the realm of myth. The Greeks believed this same myth, most prominently detailed in the myth of Prometheus. Hesiod (c. 700 BCE) wrote that Prometheus shaped man out of mud, and Athena breathed life into his clay figure, meanwhile Pandora, the first mortal woman, was formed by Hephaestus out of clay on behest of almighty Zeus. Likewise, in the ancient Babylonian creation myth, Enuma Elish, the goddess Ninhursag created humans from clay. Also, in Africa, the Yoruba culture holds that the god Obatala likewise created the human race out of clay. In Egyptian mythology, the ram headed god Khnum made people from clay in the waters of the Nile. In Chinese myth, the goddess Nuwa created the first humans from mud and clay. A Mayan myth holds that Tepeu and Kukulkn (Quetzalcoatl) made the first humans from clay, along with the Mori people of New Zealand who believe that Tne Mahuta, god of the forest, created the first woman out of clay and breathed canada goose outlet seattle life into her. The common themes of fashioning humans from clay and deities breathing life into them has been with us, in various forms, for tens of centuries.

buy canada goose jacket What, other than special pleading, can Father Longenecker offer in the way of evidence that the first few Chapters of Genesis are more historically accurate than these other myths? There is nothing that I am aware of. Moreover, why are we asked to take it on faith that the fable of a talking snake is not any canada goose outlet locations in toronto more fanciful than any other story or myth? Again, there is nothing to suggest it canada goose outlet hong kong is any less fantastic than the others, and to the contrary, it canada goose outlet online uk does not seem to be historical in the slightest. Any assumed historicity of the Garden of Eden myth is merely a case of special pleading which is proved in the very next sentence when Longenecker claims these stories are based in real events. As we have seen, however, we can find no “real” events which would demarcate canada goose outlet in canada this myth from a long history of equivalent myths. buy canada goose jacket

Canada Goose sale Maybe we have overlooked a specific element unique to the Adam and Eve story which somehow ties it to genuine history? Let’s see: are talking snakes, full of guile and charm, perhaps a historical reality? Nope. Maybe a tree of life/knowledge with magical fruit? No, I’m afraid not. Why not? Because this too is a canada goose uk site common theme in various world religions, according to Wikipedia: Canada Goose sale

buy canada goose jacket cheap Similar trees appear in other religions. but they would have belonged to someone in the genealogical line of Abraham. In the closest, most relevant comparison, the iconic image of the tree guarded by the canada goose outlet website legit Serpent appears on Sumerian seals; much later, it is the central feature of the Garden of the Hesperides in Greek mythology, where the guardian serpent receives the name Ladon. buy canada goose jacket cheap

canada goose coats The Greek serpent Ladon guards the magic golden apples, which either connotes a borrowing or a shared source regarding the tree we find in the Garden of Eden having magical fruit and being guarded by a serpent. The themes are just too congruent to discount: tree of knowledge, magic fruit, guardian serpents and the like. Meanwhile Buddhist mythology claims the king of the canada goose jacket outlet uk serpents Mucalinda rose up and coiled itself around the meditating Buddha who sat under the Bodhi tree of knowledge. canada goose coats

canadian goose jacket Nor is the tree of life (sometimes called the tree of knowledge) unique to Christianity alone. It’s an ancient motif found in: Ancient Egypt, Assyria, the Baha’i Faith, China, Germanic paganism and Norse mythology, Jewish tradition, so too Christian tradition, India, the Turkish world, Urartu, Mesoamerica, and many other cultures too. canadian goose jacket

So canada goose jacket outlet although I do not disagree with Longenecker’s assessment about the profundity of powerful language usage and symbolism in literature, I must question his judgment when it comes to determining the difference between history and myth.

canada goose coats on sale Myth forced into Literal Representations of History canada goose coats on sale

In fact, it is commonly understood, most stories are predicated on the human experience and incorporate real events as a way to make their themes more engaging. What I find perplexing though, is without any evidence, how Christians can claim their story is historically valid whereas all the rest aren’t. As we have seen, this is false. There is nothing to distinguish the Adam and Eve story as anything other than myth.

canada goose store The fact of the matter is, we know human experience is directly tied to history in other words it constitutes our history but books of fable and myth which relate to the greater human experience are, in themselves, not valid substitutes for any specified history. It’s best to keep this in mind when claiming that certain myths are historically true rather than simply containing historically viable artifacts. After all, King Kong climbed the Empire State Building, but this doesn’t make the urban jungle climbing antics of King Kong historically true. We all know it’s a fiction with historical elements and artifacts. Whereas, with the Adam and Eve fable, the only historical fact seems to be that men and women are known to exist. But this is not a strong enough basis to claim the overall story is based on history. After all, monkeys exist, but we don’t automatically assume that King Kong must have been real because monkeys are real. This is faulty reasoning, and it is a mistake religious believers frequently make when they want to gleam a literal meaning from a metaphor or myth. canada goose store

The Christian historian Thom Stark, in his book canada goose clothing uk The Human Faces of God, clarifies this point when he talks about another Bible story habitually mistaken as a literal representation of history, which is the story of Jonah and his “whale.” Stark asserts, “Aspects of the story such as Jonah’s being swallowed by a large fish, then spat out in one piece onto dry land canada goose outlet legit several days later, are big clues that what we are dealing with is a fictional short story with canada goose outlet store new york a theological message.”.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *